Layout:
Home > Should we have a 3rd kid?

Should we have a 3rd kid?

June 4th, 2014 at 02:59 pm

I want a third kid, my DH is not sure. He isn't sure we can afford it financially. He isn't sure we have the time or energy to support a third child. He isn't sure about our family dynamic. I'll admit I always planned to get pregnant this summer and have a third kid in 2015, I turned 35 recently.

But we're planning on moving and giving up our income in 2016. So my DH is worried about another mouth to feed and no income. I don't believe we'll be without an income, nor do we need much income to live I believe. But my DH is hesitant to add another child. He's worried that having another kid now will delay his job search. That he won't have the time to do it. caring for 2 kids and adding a third. He's probably not wrong.

But I am struggling with not having a third period. No we haven't done anything permanent. We agreed to the snip after we're done but that's not even been brought up. Nor have we gotten rid of any baby gear or clothes. If anything we've both been saving and storing clothes, shoes, gear. We both had assumed we'd have a third. But now what?

Do I just put aside all my baby things? Realize that the sacrifice of moving will be the third child? Will I regret it? Can I still do it in another 3 years when my kids might be 5 and 7? I'll be 38 at that time. Could I get pregnant at that age easily? Am I missing my window? Will I regret the sacrifice?

I mean we did have a heartfelt talk the other night and the truth hurts to write that my DH said if we weren't going to move we'd be talking of having kiddo number 3. I am just struggling right now with this decision.

I wonder if I shouldn't have had my kids earlier? That is probably my one regret.

11 Responses to “Should we have a 3rd kid?”

  1. ceejay74 Says:
    1401894880

    Could you wait until his job search is over? It might not be 3 years, maybe just a year, year and a half. I mean obviously it gets a bit harder statistically to conceive and carry to term the older you get, but 36, 37 is not that old. I was 35 when I had my first.

    Just a thought.

  2. creditcardfree Says:
    1401897191

    Moving vs having a child? I'd pick a child first and move later. We only have two children, I never wanted to be outnumbered. That's just me. Trust your instincts. I can't imagine one more child is much more expensive, other than the college factor. You are frugal and do well with your money...people have more kids on less ALL the time.

  3. laura Says:
    1401899373


    Why do you want a third child? I ask that as a simple question that only you can answer. Ideally, you and your husband should share a vision for your family and both be on board. And I say this as someone who has been married 24+ years, had seven pregnancies and five surviving children. And the span on my children is seven years. Our faith life has always given us the peace of mind that we would be able to provide for our children. We live in a HCOLA and I am a SAHM just now returning to work as my husband prepares for a job in ministry. I should add that I am not uneducated and did get a Masters degree before having my first. In my opinion, not have a child because of a move makes me question whether you should be having a third child at all. Though of course, this is all talk and the minute that you see that + sign in the window on the pregnancy test, your husband will be over the moon. I think that men tend to overanalyze. And we are the people that have more kids on less, but we have a grand time at life and wouldn't have it any other way.

  4. LivingAlmostLarge Says:
    1401899508

    ceejay, we aren't moving without a job until 2016, unless something dire happens. Layoff? Then move sooner. That would mean I wouldn't get pregnant until 2016 or 2017 making me 38 probably if we decided to do it. DI you have trouble conceiving ceejay?

    CCF, I don't want to move later because our oldest will be 6 already and going into first grade. Already I feel guilty waiting that long. We are doing it to save money for move without jobs. I have to reflect for sure more. Having a third now and waiting longer means short changing the first two right?

    I need to reflect more.

  5. LivingAlmostLarge Says:
    1401900012

    Laura, why is choosing to not have a child because of a move make us bad parents? I won't have a kid without DH being on board. I always said a no outweighed a yes. And we've been together 15 years and always said we'd see how we felt and where we were. We didn't plan a set number of kids, just wanted to go with the flow. So I feel not complete without a third. I'd like to experience a boy. I'd like to feel like our kids have one more playmate.

    Where do you live? Is it NY, BOS, DC, SF, or SD/LA? I consider those places HCOLA. Everything else is tier below. Do you live by family or have any help? We do not. I'm not complaining we made a choice. And now our choice is to move closer to family. We can't visit our families by car ever. Physically you can't fly across an ocean. And we can't see our parents with less than 7 hours on a plane. We just can't.

    But we hope to change our circumstances with this move.

  6. ceejay74 Says:
    1401900424

    LAL, no trouble conceiving. Normal labor and healthy baby, though I did need a C section at the end. I do know at least four people in their late 30s who miscarried their first try but successfully had children after that. The fact you've had two kids is in your favor I believe. My mom had me when she was a month shy of 40, but I was her 5th kid.

    I understand balancing practicality with desire to have kids. My husband really struggled when we had a 2-year-old and a newborn and he had a more-than-full-time job as well as half-time college. It's hard to be stretched so thin and not feel like you're being a good parent OR giving the other parts all the attention they could use.

  7. creditcardfree Says:
    1401903598

    How is waiting longer short changing your children? Because they are older with a younger child in the house? My sister in law just had her fourth baby at 40 (she said it was very hard physically), her oldest is 10, the third oldest was four when the baby was born. I guess my point, is there is no perfect way to have a family. I think the plan to keep reflecting on it and having discussions will clarify things for you at some point.

  8. laura Says:
    1401908608


    @ LAL, Never meant to insinuate those to not have a child would make you and your DH a bad parent. I was commenting more to the lack of meeting of minds. I think I said I thought it was best to have a shared vision for your family and open and honest communication with your husband about whether this is a decision that is right for you. When I married my husband, we knew we were open to however many children we were given. We were young and new we wanted to wait at least a few years to get ourselves educated, travel, and be homeowners; that said, had a child been conceived it still would have been a blessing and would have changed our plans accordingly.

    I live in affluent suburbia of Chicago, so you can count that as a HCOLA area. I didn't have family to help when my kids were young, though my parents are now returned and do help out quite a bit. My kids are growing up with kids who vacation in warm places every Christmas holiday, get new Uggs every single season, and have parents who indulge almost every whim (think brand new cars on 16th birthdays). And, oh yeah, these people don't sacrifice to send their kids to Catholic high schools either. My kids finally got on a plane last summer for the first time ever. They help cover the expenses of their expensive hobbies (club soccer and Irish dance). The normal family size in my neighborhood is 4.3 with dual-professional parents and a nanny to help. We are seven living on a financial analyst-turned-deacon salary. We could probably be accused of having too many kids than we can afford, though everyone is clothed, fed and educated.

    I suppose that I feel somewhat bad for your situation because I know what a blessing children are and I can tell you would love to have another one. It must be difficult to have a husband who doesn't share your view, or is reluctant to because of societal pressures. I am rooting for you though and hope that he can work his way through this angst because I think there is nothing more important than family. For me, a large one is a blessing.

  9. Nika Says:
    1401913093

    Besides the obvious financial considerations like schools and having 3 kids in college at the same time, needing a bigger place, etc... there are other considerations.

    For me it is fear. Even though I was completely healthy with no risk factors, a fluke of nature just happened in my fist (twin) pregnancy. It was terrifying and heartbreaking. Frown And it taught me that there is no guarantee of a great outcome. In waiting rooms of children hospitals and pediatric specialist I saw kids with extreme mental and physical disabilities and it became real to me that this can happen to anyone at any time and some of them can't be screened for. Before this, I just assumed since I'm healthy I was going to have a healthy baby, but my pregnancy made me face the reality that it is not so, and that a pregnancy is a RISK of unknown magnitude, and that is something I have to consider.

  10. Redraidernurse Says:
    1401940288

    I think all of your questions you brought up are valid. My biggest concerns would be that you will regret for the rest of your life choosing to not have a 3rd. I have heard too many people express regret over not having more children because that is something you cannot change unless you adopt.

    My second concern would be if you put off pregnancy another few years, due to advanced maternal age your chances of certain conditions with the baby increase. For example, down syndrome. At age 20, it's a 1 in 2,000 chance. At age 30, it's 1 in 1,000. At age 35 it's 1 in 350. At age 40 it's 1 in 100. At age 45 it's 1 in 10.

    You say your DH is worried about another mouth to feed, but kids that young (age 2) really aren't huge eaters. Why is having another child going to delay his job search?

  11. Looking Forward Says:
    1402035293

    It's tough, I think about having a third too, but also about how much money kids cost.

Leave a Reply

(Note: If you were logged in, we could automatically fill in these fields for you.)
*
Will not be published.
   

* Please spell out the number 4.  [ Why? ]

vB Code: You can use these tags: [b] [i] [u] [url] [email]